The actual 'teacake' debate.

[SO•Huski]

Image 1 is a traditional teacake.

Image 2 is a brand of sweet treat called a "Teacake" in reality both are teacakes but its the more traditional (IMG 1) that you would define a "Teacake" if you're older, but in more recent years children have been bought up with image 2 being teacakes.

So my opinion (based on fact) are both teacakes in reality. If you want a definitive answer? It depends on how you were bought up.